joeartguy's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[P vs Z]

It was more epic than I could have imagined. Never have I seen such struggle and pathos between a cutout zebra and some penguins with a banana. This is truly a battle for the ages. Well done.

[Cliff's 2011 Reel]

This made me want to watch your full length animations. What higher praise can I offer? It was great, mission accomplished!

karr420 responds:

thanks! all my old animations on this site are from 7-10 years ago haha, they are a bit dated.

[My Minecraft experience]

This was good, and I think it was funnier because it was in Polish. Good work!

[Penny the Possessed Baby!]

Hilarious, but you need to fix your framing. I see a re-upload in your future.

[Stainville Episode 2]

Just plain great from beginning to end. Technically the animation was smooth, the directing was sharp, the designs were original and interesting, and the sound quality and music were excellent. The content, though, was a whole different array of funny -- in particular the quick throwaway takes, which a lot of writers neglect.

That you took every take as a new opportunity for crazy kept me glued to the screen, slightly off balance and swept along. I very seldom give out a full five, but you totally earned one. Every bit of work paid off here, and I loved it.

[Some Birds Have Teeth.]

I don't ask for art shorts to have a plot, but this could have used some sort of narrative. Even as a series of (possibly intended to be nightmarish) images, there was no thematic or conceptual thread that I could pick up on. In the absence of anything tying them together into a powerful whole, this is only a disquieting jumble instead of the more disturbing and forceful material that I suppose must have been intended.

Even installations of paintings tend to have a thematic thread to make the individual pieces more powerful and affecting. A stronger core idea could have really helped you out here.

[Satty & The Pop Series 22]

Hockey sticks and Canadian porn! What's not to like? Bonus half star for gratuitous use of Rush.

Pop-Tart responds:

True patriot love, son

[The Poketman]

Very, very stupid -- impressively so! I applaud your lack of pretense, and fine use of jingly eight-bit music. I like a flash that gets right to the point!

[Meme City]

Cool story, bro!

A simplistic pastiche of unoriginal ideas I've seen a million times. In other words, a surefire hit! I'm taking out my checkbook right now!

Please work Mudkips and more desu into future episodes.