joeartguy's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Insomnicat]

I enjoy your poorly planned and amateurishly filmed puppet show. Keep up the good work.

Quowiz responds:

hahaha thanks at least you enjoy it :)

[Breakups]

Well done, with excellent narration. You get an extra half star from me for gratuitous Roddy Piper.

[X-Men: Messiah Complex 3]

Once again, thanks for making a cartoon about these comics in which I was mildly interested, but nowhere near enough to buy and read them. You're doing God's work.

[Loopdeloop - Ritual]

This is an excellent loop. I just wish it were in flash so it would actually loop. I could have watched it through a few more times (without restarting manually).

[Bugg & Mr. Hill]

It's pretty clear they both had it coming. With Hill's gangsta demeanor and Bugg's petty criminal background, they really have only themselves to blame for a lifestyle that led them to this point. The police are just doing their job, and having to deal with thugs like those two makes it difficult for everyone.

[Fred's Birthday]

I enjoyed your primitive, disjointed cartoon. It was worth watching and I was entertained.

[Steadfast Stanley]

What a great film -- moving and simply delightful.

Also smooth animation, fine expressions, great sound mixing and use of incidental music and sound effects. Your shot framing and tracking is also excellent -- your storyboards must have been delightful. Thanks for sharing all your hard work with us!

[Marcus & Kitchen: Shoot for the Stars]

Excellent styling and good timing! The voices were pleasing and the 8-bit music was very appropriate.

Barnhouse responds:

Thank Joeartguy, we tried our best to have everything work well, and we are glad to hear you feel it turned out well

[Literally Family Guy]

This isn't funny, so I gave you an extra half star for accuracy.

Squishy-Bones responds:

Thanks man, you're the best!

[The Spider and The Tree]

You have a good idea, and your animation is fluid and funny. Your upload aspect is incorrect, and it could use sound and a replay button. You might be better using a "flash ActionScript camera" to frame your shots (it's a simple little scripted object that allows you to do the kinds of pans and zooms you're doing without changing the original movie).

This is a good first try! Fix your frame aspect.